Archive for January, 2009

Workplace Violence from terminations and lay-offs

Thursday, January 29th, 2009

A man kills his 5 young children and their mother before committing suicide.  While this frequently occurs in domestic violence cases, the tragedy that unfolded near LA last week stems from when Ervin Lupoe, the suspect, and his wife lost their jobs as medical technicians in a hospital.

 While this tragedy occurred in their home, a frequent precipitant of employee based workplace violence is a termination. With an estimated 2 million jobs lost in the last 4 last months, it is expected that there will be more cases erupting.  “While not every firing of an employee leads to a firing of a gun, there are some common characteristics that may provide clues for prevention”, stated Johnny Lee, Director of Peace at Work. 

While the risk may be apparent when an employee is fired for misconduct or job performance, many hard working and dependable people lose their jobs due to simple economics. They, like the increasing thousands across our nation, are simply being laid off.  But this lack of personal reason does not exempt the employer from revenge.  In November of 2006, in Jamaica, a female manager was gunned down as she walked into her workplace. While no suspect had been caught, numerous employees had just been laid off, generating much animosity and resentment. 

More recently, it was a reduction in force that lead to the murder of top level management including the CEO of semi-conductor company in California.  Engineer Jing Hua Wu, 47, was just laid off when he returned late on a November afternoon with a handgun.

On a deeper level, an employee may self-identify with their position and losing their job is a serious blow to their self-ego. Reggie Edwards had worked for his Whitehall, OH employer for about five years ago but it was central to his identity. “That was his life,” his sister later said. “He would eat, sleep and dream Safe Auto. I mean, that’s how dedicated he was to his company.”  It could very well be that losing that identity leads to desperate actions.  It was March of 2005 Edwards went back to his car after being fired, grabbed a gun and returned to the building.  He fired shots and then took his former a co-worker hostage who he released just before he killed himself.

In a Sarasota, Florida, 55-year-old Jacquelyn Ferguson knew that she was going to be fired. She had allegedly been abusing prescription medication and her job performance suffered.  But the victim, office manager 45-year-old Denise Keyworth, didn’t have the fateful meeting yet. Ferguson shot and killed Keyworth, despite the fact that the manager had the employee over for Christmas dinner last year.  Ferguson then went home to commit suicide.

While the day of the termination has risks, many ex-employees commit violence the next day, even during a Christmas party. Just last month, Benjamin Banky, CEO of a natural health food supplier in Canada, was killed during the company party. Eric Kirkpatrick, who had lost his job the day before, exacted his revenge amid the snacks, presents and decorations.

But there are effective prevention and intervention measures that can be utilized to help mitigate the risk.  A webinar offered on January 29th, 2009 will focus on the occurence and best practices. 

There is nothing ‘normal’ about abusers

Monday, January 26th, 2009
In an recent email post I sent about the Christmas party massacre by Bruce Pardo,  I tried to convey that the assailant did not fit any sterotype of a pathological murder.   No record and apparently recorded mental health issues. 
it does illustrate how desperation can lead a ‘normal’ person to commit an incredibly heinous act. While we do not have a full psychological profile of Pardo, he reportedly had a clean record, no history of violence and was active in his church.
The reference to normal generated a number of responses, including one that I have from a colleague who gave me permission to include a part of his response-
I appreciated your letter, but I think you’ve inadvertently supported a couple common myths about domestic violence.  Calling him “normal” is on the same continuum as the media coverage that portrays him as a “nice guy,” when apparently he wasn’t.  And speaking about the stress of job loss and finances begs the reader to confirm the myth that job stress, or any kind of stress (loss of the dog, etc.) or poor coping skills, causes DV.  What I’ve been taught is that one person (usually a man) having a mindset that s/he gets to control the person s/he’s dating or married to, causes DV.  Stress can make that dynamic worse, but my understanding is that it’s not the cause.   
 Certainly such stresses should be taken into consideration in any threat assessment, as you suggest.  But the stresses are not the cause - they just make it worse.  
His contact information, again, with permission-

 

Ben Atherton-Zeman, Maynard, MA USA
Actor, Comedian, Feminist and Husband
Presenting a One-Man Play: “Voices of Men,” http://www.voicesofmen.org
Booking information: 978-897-3619

 

I may have used a poor choice of words but certainly there is nothing ‘normal’ about this man.   I was trying to address another myth that those who commit homicide are these noticiably deranged characters.  
Another point that I failed to emphasize is that the stressors the he faced can be seen a correlations, not causal to the action.  I am not sure if I can get far if I tried to get “into the minds” of the perpetrators I have studied to anaylyse their motives or determine why they do what they do.  
What we can do is take an objective look at what is going on their world and notice the risk factors that have been associated with such extreme behavior. 
But also known is the myriad of problems and losses that he faced. The massacre occurred less than a week before the divorce was finalized. He had apparently lost his electrical engineering job just months before which complicated his financial struggles.

“I was not given a severance package from my last employer at termination and I am not receiving any other income,” wrote Pardo, who also was denied unemployment benefits. “I am desperately seeking work.”

Among those, his previous girlfriend had sued him for the $340,000 in medical bills from an accident which left his 9 year old son brain damaged bound to a wheel chair. The guilt of this incident may have added to his mental torment as the condition was a result of a pool accident when he was watching the child. As a final, very personal loss, as part of the recent divorce, he lost his Akita dog, Saki, to whom he was known to be very attached. 

The main issue is that I do not try to suggest that abusers who commit murder are just normal men under pressure.  There are deeper issues that is the subject of many books and message boards.  But if there are any lessons that can be applied, it is in looking at cases broadly and recognizing factors that may make them more likely to kill. 
Comments are welcomed